The country’s flood insurance market is slowly transitioning toward private insurers providing additional options to the federal government’s program for those seeking coverage, according to a new AM Best report.

But private sector carriers are being selective, tending to avoid risks in flood-prone areas and concentrating more on commercial properties than homeowners, an AM Best report shows.

According to Best’s Market Segment Report, “Appetite for Flood Risk Among Private Insurers Still Small,” more than 70 percent of overall private flood premium has been generated from commercial property exposures.

Also the report finds that private insurers tend to avoid flood-prone areas, noting that Florida experiences tropical systems more frequently than any other state and represents about one third of the total National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) insured value. Yet Florida represents only about a quarter of the total flood premium, partially illustrating the larger issue that the NFIP is subject to an inherent risk of adverse selection.

“If private insurers are able to price risks individually, they will cherry-pick the best risks with pricing better than the NFIP’s subsidized rates, leading to further adverse selection,” said Christopher Graham, senior industry analyst, AM Best.

The NFIP still bears the heaviest burden of the U.S. flood market, but private flood insurers generated almost $3.1 billion in total direct premium during 2016-2020. The $735 million in direct premium in 2020 represented the largest amount during that period.

Online Platform Allows Agents, Buyers to Compare, Buy Flood Insurance

The slow shift toward more private sector involvement comes a time when the federally operated National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) notched a $20.5 billion shortfall earlier in the year, a figure that includes losses dating back to Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

The NFIP is administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which has developed Rating 2.0, a strategy to address pricing inefficiencies and curtail any adverse risk selection by moving all properties to a true risk-based rate. The new NFIP rate structure is scheduled to take effect Oct. 1, 2021.

Under Risk Rating 2.0, the annual premium rate is expected to decline for a quarter of policyholders obtaining coverage through the NFIP. However, many will see their rates increase and reach their full risk rate in approximately five years. Eventually, the new rating measures should lead to more adequately priced NFIP risks and more competitive coverage offered by private insurers.

According to Best analysts, higher premium costs for federal flood insurance “should make the private insurance pricing more competitive” and drive more insureds to the private market.

“This should help better spread the flood risk among private carriers and the NFIP, as well as create a better overall flood insurance market for customers needing the coverage,” said David Blades, associate director, AM Best.

Authorization for the NFIP is currently set to expire at the end of this month unless Congress acts to renew it.

In recent years, Congress has been unable to pass reform legislation or a long-term extension for the NFIP but has instead passed about a dozen short-term extensions. Last year, President Donald Trump signed a one-year extension passed by Congress right before the NFIP expired.

Source: AM Best

*This story ran previously in our sister publication Insurance Journal.