Airbnb Inc. on Wednesday revealed what it’s calling its “biggest change in a decade.” Beyond modifications to its user interface and nifty new bells and whistles, it’s also addressing one of the company’s greatest pain points: poor consumer protections for guests.

Airbnb will now offer a substantial set of satisfaction guarantees for guests and is staffing up an army of customer service agents to deliver on them. “There are inherent structural advantages to hotels, like product consistency and having a front desk,” explained CEO Brian Chesky over Zoom. “And it’s been an underlying assumption for many years that we really can’t meet hotels in that sense.”

AirCover for Guests is his bid to change that. “We wanted to take some of the uncertainty of Airbnb off the table,” he said, “and make the idea of being one-of-a-kind an asset, not a liability.”

Take the misadventures of San Diego-based Kelsey Swann, who was looking forward to a quiet escape in California’s Sonoma wine country with her kids, only to find the timeshare resort she booked on Airbnb was far from that ideal. First, she was given a multiple-hour runaround between three different units that were all either unavailable, unlockable or uncleaned. Then, once finally settled, the karaoke parties started, blaring through paper-thin walls from what seemed like every direction. They checked out the next morning.

To add insult to injury, during a days-long battle with customer support to get refunded for three unused nights, she had $3,500 fraudulently charged by the same host. Getting those charges reversed, she said, took several days and required extra support from her credit card company.

Amid the drama, she turned to a family travel Facebook group for advice; sympathetic comments poured in by the dozens. “Airbnb is the worst,” one group member told her. “We got nothing because the host disputed everything,” rallied another, who had been in a similar situation. “We loved using Airbnb for years—but it’s back to hotels for us,” another chimed in.

Traditionally, Airbnb will pay out the portion of a booking that a host has earned within 24 hours of check-in. If a guest’s problem hasn’t been resolved by then, the traveler has no real recourse or protection with Airbnb, and the host has little incentive beyond a poor review to make things right.

Hosts, however, have long enjoyed a wide array of insurance-like protections called AirCover for Hosts. There’s $1 million in liability insurance and another $1 million in damage protection. The plan covers messes left by pets and other deep cleaning costs, too, with generous 14-day filing windows.

AirCover for Guests nudges toward parity. It extends the window to file complaints to 72 hours and adds guarantees that customers will be rebooked or refunded when things go wrong—be it inaccurately described listings, pests or broken heaters.

Wednesday’s other brand-wide upgrades are also about creating a more user-friendly experience. There’s a redesigned homepage, the ability to search more open-endedly through categories (think “amazing pools,” “windmills” or “yurts”), and a new tool called “Split Stays” that helps travelers seamlessly line up multiple bookings for trips that last longer than two weeks.

But AirCover for Guests is unique in how it underscores the two-sided marketplace of Airbnb’s business model: satisfying both the hosts who open their homes and the guests who stay in them. And as early response indicates—hosts caught wind of the policy earlier this year—pleasing them both is difficult. While guests should be thrilled with having more time and support when things go wrong, hosts say the same policy hurts them by opening the door to scammers who want a free stay.

How It Works

The new policy will cover not just problems that arise after check-in but incidents where a host cancels a stay within 30 days of the reservation, in which cases Airbnb will automatically rebook guests into comparable (or better) homes.

That would have helped Roberta Roy, a Seattle-based mom of three who had her Rome apartment booking canceled at the last minute “because the previous guest broke the bed.” Trying to find something new on her own with just a few days to spare, she said, cost her twice as much. And calling Airbnb for help was nearly impossible thanks to an impenetrable automated phone system: “I felt like the issue could’ve been very easily addressed by Airbnb, but they were completely unreachable.”

For guests who encounter issues at the scene, getting support will now be as simple as pushing a red “help” button in the “Trips” tab of their app. This begins an official arbitration process, via text thread, with the newly expanded, better-trained Community Support team.

Assuming the host has already been contacted and was unable to offer an acceptable solution, customer service agents will have access to an automatically generated list of Airbnb properties similar to the existing booking, from which they will be able to immediately rebook the guest at no cost.

Chesky said the directive will be to upgrade a guest when in doubt: “We’d rather you be convinced this is a better home, not a worse home.”

Airbnb will also have “a second line of defense” prepared for big events and high-demand seasons, when inventory can be fully booked out.

“Let’s say it’s Palm Springs during Coachella and all the Airbnbs are booked,” said Chesky. “Our agents will also have queued up properties or hotel rooms that might be off platform.” The idea, he explained, is having more agents being able to respond in more languages, to offer solutions “in minutes or hours rather than days.”

The Early Response

Hosts were tipped off to the policy change earlier in the year and have been discussing it in Facebook hosting groups. Running through the largely negative posts are fears that guests would take advantage of the policy and claim a refund for minor, or in worse cases, fabricated complaints.

Some hosts Bloomberg spoke to in April said they were contemplating creating a website to attract their own bookings, so they wouldn’t have to deal with Airbnb’s policies and rules. Kim D., a Superhost who has properties in Western New York and Florida, said she worries that a guest could try to take advantage of the new policy and seek a refund for a minor problem. (Bloomberg is not using her last name because she worries Airbnb could remove her listings.)

A guest could stay at her property for three nights and come up with a minor issue for wanting to leave, which could risk Airbnb approving a refund, she said, adding there’s a “gray area” between what hosts, guests and the company view as worthy of reimbursement.

The company believes the new policies provide breathing room for guests. “We didn’t want to be punitive to hosts, but a lot of guests don’t check out the entire property the first day they arrive, and they discover something the second day,” Chesky said of the timeframe at an event Tuesday. “And that’s kind of a ticking time bomb—by Day 2 if you discover anything you can’t call us? So, we try to be reasonable.”

A 72-hour window would also give the host and guest more time to address the issue themselves, an Airbnb spokesperson told Bloomberg.

Chesky thinks that for most hosts, the policy should be a net benefit. “95 percent of hosts—maybe 99 percent—will be happy because they’re doing a great job. And if a host cancels or lists properties that are not as described, it kind of hurts the brand of every host,” he said.

For consumers like Swann in Sonoma, it may be too little too late. “Would I use them again? Maybe,” she said. Rome’s Roy, however, is encouraged. “We love Airbnb. We have always used Airbnb,” she said. “I’m really glad they’re addressing these issues.”

Top photo: Akos Stiller/Bloomberg